Screening Guidelines | How is HPV Detected? | Management | When Should HPV Testing Not Be Done?
Cervical Cancer Prevention
General
- Cervical cancer prevention depends upon detection and treatment of high-grade (CIN2,3) cervical lesions most likely to progress to invasive cancer in the absence of treatment.
- Two primary cervical screening tests are now in use in the US
The Pap test, which includes the conventional Pap smear and the liquid-based Pap test.
The HPV test. HPV testing in primary cervical cancer screening is presently approved only as a cotest with the Pap test for women age 30 and over. Not all insurers (specifically Medicaid and certain managed Medicaid companies) will allow for this as an alternative screening strategy. You might want to consider checking with your local laboratories and insurers for coverage of this alternative screening strategy.
Cervical cancer screening guidelines
- When to begin screening: The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) guidelines were revised in 2009 and other groups and societies are expected to conform this year. ACOG’s guideline is to defer screening until age 21, regardless of risk factors including onset of sexual activity.
- How often should screening occur?
From the onset of screening: ACOG recommends a Pap test every other year from ages 21-29, then every three years for women with a history of negative findings. Please refer to ASCCP guidelines for follow-up of women with abnormalities.
- Beginning at age 30: ACOG recommends increasing screening intervals to every three years after prior negative screening. Both the American Cancer Society (ACS) and ACOG recommend that the screening interval can be increased to 2 to 3 years after 3 consecutive normal Pap tests have been obtained. An alternative option for women age ≥30 is to screen with both a Pap test and a HPV test, and if both are negative, to be re-screened every 3 years.
- High-risk women, defined as those with HIV (or other reasons for being immunocompromised) or DES exposure in-utero, should be screened annually. Please refer to ASCCP guidelines for management of women with cervical screening abnormalities. Once negative, women with CIN2,3 should be screened annually for at least 20 years, while women with lesser abnormalities can be screened at longer intervals.
- Conventional and liquid-based cytology techniques appear similarly effective and choice of Pap technology should not alter screening interval.
- At what age should screening cease?
ACOG recommends that women with at least 3 consecutive documented satisfactory normal Pap tests within the last 10 years can cease cervical screening between the ages of 65-70, while ACS recommends these same women may cease cervical screening at age 70.
The United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends that women with adequate normal screening in the last 10 years can cease having a Pap at age 65.
- Should screening cease following hysterectomy?
All three organizations state that screening should cease following a hysterectomy if there was no CIN2,3 or cancer at the time of the hysterectomy
How accurate are cervical screening tests?
Large meta-analyses have documented that Pap tests are about 25-33% less sensitive for CIN2,3 than HPV tests but are approximately 6% more specific. Cervical screening with cytology has been successful in decreasing the projected rate (in the absence of screening) of cervical cancer in the US by 75-80% because progression of CIN3 to invasive cancer is generally a slow process, giving time for most precancer to be detected even with one or more "false negative" Pap results. Remember that 50% of cervical cancer occurs in women who have never had a Pap and another 10% in women who seldom get Paps (last Pap 5 years or more).
How is a Pap test performed?
- A spatula, or a soft plastic brush that looks like a tiny broom, is brushed entirely around the surface (portio) of the cervix to collect cells. When a spatula is used, a small spiral brush (cytobrush) is inserted into the cervical canal and rotated 180 degrees to collect cells from the endocervix. This may cause mild crampy discomfort for the patient. When two sampling devices are used to collect the cytologic specimen, it is important to obtain the exocervical sample first, followed by the endocervical sample. This will minimize contamination of the specimen by bleeding that often follows rotation of the cytobrush in the endocervical canal.
- The cells on the collection device(s) are either put directly on a glass slide or into a bottle of special liquid (ThinPrep® or SurePath™) and sent to the lab. If put directly into the liquid, a glass slide is prepared in the lab.
- At the lab the cells are stained and evaluated through a microscope by cytotechnologists (people trained to look for abnormal cells). Many labs now perform the initial evaluation of the Pap slides with an automated computer-guided microscope that identifies the slides most likely to have abnormalities for human review and marks the cells that are abnormal in appearance.
How is a High Risk HPV (hrHPV) test performed?
- Specimens for cervical HPV tests can be collected in one of two ways:
Most hrHPV testing is done directly from remaining liquid-based medium remaining after cells have been removed from the liquid-based Pap vial to create the cytology slide. Although this is routinely done from both ThinPrep® and SurePath™ liquid-based mediums, to date it has only been FDA-approved for ThinPrep®.
hrHPV tests can also be done by taking a separate brush sample from the cervix with the collection device and placed in a standard transport medium (STM).
What kinds of cells are collected from the cervix?
- The normal cervix has two types of cells on the surface: squamous cells and columnar (glandular or mucus producing) cells. Additionally, new squamous cells are identified as metaplastic cells.
Squamous cells The skin throughout the vagina and to varying degrees covering the cervix is composed of multiple layers of flat cells called squamous cells.
Columnar or glandular cells The surface of the canal that leads from the outside of the cervix to the endometrial cavity within the uterus is covered by a single layer of cells that produces mucus (part of the liquid in vaginal discharge). These cells stop at the edge of the squamous cells. This junction where the two cell types meet is called the squamocolumnar junction.
Metaplastic cells (immature squamous cells) New squamous cells at the squamocolumnar junction are continuously replacing columnar cells. These new squamous cells are called metaplastic cells. The area of cell replacement is called the transformation zone. Metaplastic cells are normal. However, metaplastic cells appear to be most vulnerable to the activity of HPV in causing abnormal cell changes. Therefore, the transformation zone and SCJ are areas where most precancerous change can be found. These cells may also be more vulnerable to the irritative effects of yeast, tampons, intercourse, spermicides, etc. Some abnormal Paps are due to these non-precancerous cell changes.
What information is reported from a Pap test?
Most cytology results are now reported using terminology called The Bethesda System (TBS). The cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) approximate equivalents are in parentheses.
- Quality of the smear: First, the cytotechnologist reading the Pap indicates whether the quality of the Pap is good (and therefore the Pap can be relied upon), or whether the quality is borderline or poor (and needs to be repeated). There are two possibilities.
Satisfactory: This is a Pap that is readable and has adequate cells. There is no excessive mucus, inflammation, blood or overlapping of cells hindering adequate assessment. One of two of the following descriptors will follow:
Metaplastic and/or columnar cells are present. This is evidence that the area on the cervix at-risk for precancerous changes (the squamocolumnar junction and transformation zone) were sampled.
Metaplastic and/or columnar cells are not present. This, however, is not a definite indication that the transformation zone was not sampled. Most Paps with lack of transformation zone cells should be repeated in one year. The exception is when the Pap is from a woman considered at higher risk due to past Pap history, cervical treatment or immunosuppression, in which the Pap should be repeated in 6 months.
Unsatisfactory: This Pap is of such poor quality that it cannot be relied upon and should be repeated. It does not mean that the Pap is abnormal. - In fact, an abnormal Pap (ASC-US, ASC-H, AGC, LSIL, HSIL, Cancer) must be read as abnormal even if it is of poor quality.
Normal:
Negative for intraepithelial lesion or malignancy (NILM): Most women (90-95%) have a normal (NILM) Pap result. This means that no abnormal cells were found and it is most likely that the cervix is normal (although, as explained above, some women will have a normal Pap but still have abnormal cell changes on the cervix, a "false negative" Pap).
Abnormal:
Atypical Squamous Cells (ASC): From 2-10% will have this Pap interpretation. This means that squamous cells are detected that do not entirely look normal, but also not entirely abnormal. There are two subcategories of ASC:
Atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASC-US): Approximately 50-60% of women having this Pap reading are entirely normal (HPV negative and no cervical disease), and 40-50% are hrHPV positive with half of those having detectable cervical changes due to HPV (mostly low-grade [mild dysplasia, CIN I]). Approximately 6-9% will have high-grade changes (moderate or severe dysplasia, CIN2 or 3) and rarely a cervical cancer (approximately 1/1000 ASC-US).
Atypical squamous cells-cannot rule out high grade (ASC-H): A small percentage of ASC Pap test results are ASC-H. This means that some cells are abnormal enough to be suggestive, but not definitive, of a high-grade lesion. From 60-80% of women with ASC-H test positive for hrHPV, and the risk of CIN2,3+ is much higher than that of ASC-US.
Atypical glandular cells (AGC): AGC is an uncommon Pap interpretation (0.2-0.8%). This means that glandular cells are detected that do not look entirely normal, but also not entirely abnormal. Women with AGC Pap results may be normal, or have squamous cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) or glandular adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS), cervical or endometrial adenocarcinoma, fallopian tube, ovarian or other glandular cancers. Approximately 50-70% or more of women with this Pap reading will be found to be normal, but this Pap interpretation has more risk of squamous and glandular precancer or cancer than any other Pap interpretation other than HSIL. Therefore, women with this Pap result should have colposcopy and endocervical sampling. Additionally, all patients with AGC that are interpreted as "atypical endometrial cells", or have abnormal unexplained bleeding at any age, or a history of anovulation, or are over the age of 35 should also have an endometrial biopsy. As with cervical squamous lesions, most glandular cervical precancer and cancer is associated with hrHPV while uterine cancers found after AGC Pap results are not.
Low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (LSIL): From 2-4% or more will have this Pap result. In younger women (≤35) this Pap test reading is almost always due to an active HPV infection as 83-94% would test positive for HPV if tested. Women over the age of 35 may have cell changes that are not related to HPV but are read as LSIL. Most of these "misclassified" cell changes are due to declining estrogen levels or other effects of the aging process on our skin cells. As a result only about 50% of women over the age of 35 with a LSIL Pap would test positive for HPV. In order to triage LSIL in estrogen-weak environments such as that in post-menopausal women, an acceptable triage option would be to test for hrHPV and if negative, to repeat the cytology in a year. Over all age groups, about 70% of women will have cervical or vaginal cell changes due to HPV that can be identified on further evaluation (colposcopy). Most of these changes are low-grade [mild dysplasia, CIN I] but approximately 10-28% will have high-grade changes (moderate or severe dysplasia, CIN2 or 3).
High-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL): Typically from 0.3-0.8% will have this Pap result. Over 90% with HSIL will have cell changes due to hrHPV. The majority have high-grade cervical changes (moderate or severe dysplasia, CIN2 or 3), but some will have only low-grade changes or no abnormality detected at colposcopy. Any woman with a high-grade Pap (HSIL) should be evaluated by colposcopy to determine whether CIN2,3 or cancer requiring treatment is present.
Cancer: Rarely a Pap will be read as suspicious for cancer. Women with this reading should be evaluated immediately.
If a patient has an abnormal Pap, how should she be evaluated?
There are three options for evaluating an abnormal Pap depending on the degree of abnormality of the Pap result and whether the patient is an adolescent (age 20 and under) or an adult (age 21 and over).
- Colposcopy: This is the first step in management of all women ages 21 years and older with any abnormal Pap result except ASC-US. A colposcope is a microscope mounted on a stand which is placed outside the vagina allowing the clinician to look at the cervix for cell changes. Colposcopy is the cornerstone in the initial evaluation of all abnormal cytology results. There are only three situations in which the initial evaluation of an abnormal Pap may be by means other than by colposcopy. These are (1). Adolescents age 20 and under should not be evaluated initially by colposcopy, (2). Women age 21 and over with ASC-US have the option of initial triage with either repeat Pap at 6 and 12 months or "reflex" hrHPV testing, and (3). Post-menopausal women with LSIL have the option of "reflex" hrHPV testing.
- Repeating the Pap test: The ASCCP Guidelines provide the option of repeating the Pap in the initial management of women of any age with ASC-US and for adolescents with ASC-US or LSIL. Repeating the Pap every 6 months until there are two consecutive normal Pap results is also an option for women age 21 and over not found to have CIN2,3 or AIS at colposcopy when originally referred for the evaluation of ASC-US, ASC-H, or LSIL. Repeat cytology at 12 months is recommended for all adolescents with ASC-US or LSIL.
- HPV testing: The 2006 ASCCP Guidelines provide the option of testing for HPV in the initial triage of women age 21 and over with ASC-US and post-menopausal women with LSIL. HPV testing should never be used in the evaluation of adolescents nor in the initial management of women with any other Pap abnormality. HPV testing is also an option in the post-colposcopy management of women not found to have CIN2,3 or AIS at colposcopy and originally referred for the evaluation of ASC-US, ASC-H, AGC-NOS or LSIL. It is not used in the post-colposcopy management of women referred for evaluation of AGC "cannot rule out high grade" or HSIL.
How is HPV detected?
- Most HPV infections are detected only when they cause clinically-apparent disease: external warts; cervical, vaginal, vulvar, anal or penile pre-cancers or cancers.
-
The presence of HPV in some epithelial tissues (cervix, vagina, anus) can be detected by:
Cervical cytology (the Pap test) is an indirect test for the effect of HPV on cervical and vaginal cells. LSIL, particularly in young women, and HSIL Pap results are almost always due to hrHPV.
Molecular tests: There are presently two FDA-approved HPV tests that test for a panel of high-risk, or carcinonogenic, HPV types. These are Hybrid Capture® 2 (hc2) [Qiagen Corporation, Gaithersburg, MD], and the Invader® Third Wave HPV test (Third Wave Technologies, Inc., Hologic, Inc., Marlborough, MA). In addition there is now also an FDA-approved type-specific HPV 16/18 test (Cervista® HPV 16/18, Hologic, Inc., Marlborough, MA). All three tests are approved off of the ThinPrep® liquid-based cytology medium (ThinPrep®, Preservcyt, Hologic, Marlborough, MA) and can also be collected in Standard Viral Transport Medium (STM). Specimens are collected from the cervix with standard Pap test collection tools, or if placed in an STM, are collected with a "Christmas tree brush" provided with the manufacturer’s STM collection tube. HPV testing may be accomplished with collection devices and transport medium used for cervical cytology. Collection of HPV swabs from external genitalia has generally not been helpful and is not recommended.
Visual inspection with or without application of acetic acid and/or magnification can be used to detect external lesions as well as lesions on the cervix, in the vagina, penis or in the anal canal, but is very non-specific.
Anal screening is likely to become increasingly utilized due to the 90% association of HPV with anal cancer and increasing anal cancer rates, particularly in HIV and immunocompromized populations.
Where is hrHPV testing potentially useful and what tests should be used?
- hrHPV testing is incorporated in both screening guidelines of the American Cancer Society (ACS) and American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) and in the American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology (ASCCP) and ACOG guidelines for the management of abnormal cervical cytology and cervical neoplasia.
- HPV testing must be for hrHPV types only and should use a Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved or equivalent test that has undergone peer review in a rigorous, masked evaluation involving an adequate sample size.
- Testing for low-risk HPV types that do not cause cervical cancer has no clinical benefit and cannot be justified for clinical testing.
- Other than the indications listed below in the section "Screening" and the section "Management" HPV testing generally should not be done because it potentially creates more harm than benefit.
Screening
- Both Hybrid Capture® 2 (hc2) and Cervista™ are FDA-approved to be used as a cotest with the Pap test in the primary screening of women age 30 and over.
- Cotesting provides a margin of safety for at least 3 years, with recent studies suggesting safety may extend for at least 6 years.
- Excessive screening (cotesting more often than every three years) all too often identifies transient HPV infections and minor cytologic abnormalities that would have resolved on their own if given wider screening intervals.
- Hence, testing more often in women who are at virtually no risk of having precancer adds cost without benefit and likely may cause harm as women undergo needless colposcopy and destructive cervical procedures to identify and treat cervical lesions that would have resolved spontaneously. Cotesting is sensitive enough that persistent lesions--the only kind that can eventually lead to cancer--will be detected at the next 3-year visit, and the risk of cancer during that interval is extremely low.
- Therefore, cotesting with the Pap and HPV test in women 30 years or older should not be done more frequently than every 3 years when results of both tests are negative.
Management
Initial triage of Pap negative/HPV test positive cotest results age 30 and over
- Cotesting with a Pap and a HPV test is 95-100% sensitive for CIN3+ in most studies and is increasingly used with a Pap to significantly decrease the risk of a false negative screening result (when disease is present on the cervix but is not detected on the Pap) and to increase the screening interval for women with negative results on both tests.
- There are two follow-up options for women with negative Pap results but a positive hrHPV test. Both use HPV testing:
Repeat the Pap and HPV test in 12 months with referral to colposcopy of any woman with either an abnormal Pap or a positive HPV test.
"Reflex" test the remaining sample (liquid-based Pap or STM) with the Cervista® HPV 16/18 test and do colposcopy on all HPV 16/18 positive women. Women positive for the hrHPV panel test but negative for HPV 16/18 should have a repeated Pap and HPV test in 12 months.
Initial triage of abnormal cervical cytology
- There are only two uses for hrHPV testing in the initial triage of abnormal cytology
ASC-US (atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance) for women only age 21 and over. In most studies approximately one half of the women age 21 and older with ASC-US has HPV (and is therefore at-risk of having cervical neoplasia). hrHPV positive ASC-US requires colposcopic referral. hrHPV negative ASC-US is very low-risk for CIN3+ and should have a repeated Pap in one year. ASC-US is the most common Pap abnormality.
LSIL (low grade squamous intraepithelial lesion) in postmenopausal women: Testing for hrHPV in younger women with a diagnosis of LSIL is of no value due to the high frequency (> 80%) of a positive test. It is acceptable to use HPV testing to triage postmenopausal women with LSIL due to a lower incidence of HPV-positive LSIL in this population and low-risk for CIN3+ for HPV negative LSIL. Postmenopausal women with a LSIL Pap test result and a negative hrHPV test should have a Pap repeated in one year.
Post-colposcopy
-
HPV testing is appropriate in the following circumstances post-colposcopy:
Post-colposcopy management of women of any age with initial cytologic result of Atypical Glandular Cells -"not otherwise specified"(AGC-NOS) when initial workup does not identify a high grade lesion Women who are HPV negative can be evaluated at 12 months, whereas women with HPV positive AGC-NOS will require an evaluation at 6 months.
Post-colposcopy management of women 21 and older with initial cytologic results of ASC-US, ASC-H or LSIL (when initial colposcopy does not identify a high grade lesion). Such women have the option of follow-up with either a Pap at 6 and 12 months or a hrHPV test at 12 months.
Post-treatment surveillance
-
There are two options for evaluation of the success of cervical treatment for CIN2,3:
A hrHPV test 6 to 12 months post-treatment. Women positive on the HPV test should have colposcopy and endocervical sampling, whereas women HPV negative may return to strict annual screening for at least 20 years.
Repeat cytology every 6 months with or without accompanying colposcopy until two consecutive cytology results are negative. Women with ≥ASC-US should have colposcopy and endocervical sampling.
When should HPV testing not be done?
-
Routine cervical cancer screening (cotesting with the Pap) in women less than 30 years of age. The high rate of HPV detection in women under the age of 30 with a normal cervix precludes the use of this test in younger women. The American Cancer Society (ACS) and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) have both endorsed as an option the primary screening of women only ≥30 with this combination testing. However, not all insurers (specifically Medicaid and certain managed Medicaid companies) will allow for this as an alternative screening strategy. You might want to consider checking with your local laboratories and insurers for coverage of this alternative screening strategy.
-
Routine screening with hrHPV testing and cervical cytology more often than every 3 years for women 30 years and older whose tests were negative at last screen
-
Initial triage or management of adolescents (age 20 and younger) with any abnormal cytologic result. Further, if hrHPV testing is inadvertently performed, the results should not be used to influence patient management
-
Initial triage of LSIL (except for post-menopausal women)
-
Initial triage of ASC-H, HSIL or AGC/AIS in women of any age
-
Testing to determine whether a woman with a significantly abnormal Pap (low- or high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion [LSIL or HSIL]) is positive for a low-risk or a high-risk HPV type. Since the majority of women with these Pap readings are positive for high-risk HPV types, it is neither helpful nor cost-effective to test for HPV under these circumstances.
-
As a STI screen. HPV testing should never be used as a screening test for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) because HPV is so common and, unlike most STDs, has no direct anti-viral treatment that would follow detection.
-
Testing to determine whether to give a vaccine to prevent HPV: The two HPV panel tests do not specifically identify HPV types, and although the recently-approved Cervista™ HPV 16/18 test could be used, it does not identify whether one or both types are present. Additionally, women might have had an HPV 16/18 infection that might have regressed, and would come back negative; however, the vaccine efficacy for these women might be less. Additionally, there is no commercially available, validated serologic test that would identify past exposure to HPV types. The cost of prevaccination screening of all sexually active women would escalate the cost of vaccine administration and create further barriers. Hence, the vaccination recommendations are not predicated on HPV test results.
|